top of page

My Whisky Rating System Explained

While the traditional 100-point or 10-point whisky rating system offers a basic idea of the quality, they don’t always translate to a drinker’s personal experience. They merely reflect the experts’ opinions on the product. An affordable whisky might receive the same score as a rare one, yet the enjoyment can be vastly different. This is especially true for those new to the world of whisky.


Hence, I find it crucial to establish categories that can serve as a guide for enthusiasts, connoisseurs and anyone seeking an entry point to whisky.



A Classification System for the Whisky Journey


To empower enthusiasts on their whisky exploration, I’ve developed a classification system that goes beyond points and delves into the experience itself. Here are the four categories:


  1. Introductory Whisky: Perfect for beginners or those who don’t regularly drink whisky. These expressions are approachable and easy to sip. Think: Glenmorangie Original 10-Year-Old, Jameson Irish Whiskey.

  2. Casual Whisky: Appealing to the curious drinker who wants to venture beyond, but haven’t fully developed their palate. Their sensory repertoire is forming. Think: Macallan 12-Year-Old, Kavalan Concertmaster Port Cask Finish

  3. Intermediate Whisky: These whiskies demand a slightly more developed palate to appreciate their nuances. They offer a richer sensory experience for those ready to delve deeper. Think: Highland Park 18-Year-Old, Glenmorangie A Tale of Winter

  4. Complex Whisky: Crafted with a blend of various cask finishes, ages, grains or whiskies. These whiskies are designed for seasoned palate. Think: Johnnie Walker Blue Label Ghost and Rare Glenury Royal, Mortlach 20-Year-Old


Finally, to provide a well-rounded assessment, each whisky evaluated on five key aspects:

  • Aroma 

  • Taste

  • Complexity

  • Approachability

A rating system of 0 to 5 (with 0 being the lowest and 5 the highest) is used for each factor. The final score is determined by the average.


This system aims to:

  • Provide a more user-friendly guide compared to traditional point-based ratings.

  • Empower enthusiasts to discover whiskies that align with their preferences and experience level.

  • Offer a clearer picture of the actual drinking experience each whisky provides.


Empowering Your Whisky Exploration

By using this classification system, whisky enthusiasts can navigate the vast world of this spirit with more confidence and knowledge. So, raise a glass and embark on your whisky journey with a newfound sense of exploration!

I hope this helps in understanding the classification I’ve applied in the reviews.

3 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Kommentare


Tokyo-Whisky-Library-Japan-1440x720.jpg

Viaje a Japón 2025

Nivel 2.png

Cursos y certificaciones

FullSizeRender_34981875-af91-409b-81af-adf823cb253a.webp

Cata especial de Ardbeg CDMX

IMG_8723.JPEG

Noche de Burns

bottom of page